2

I was wondering if there was any way to solve the equation $a^x=x^b$ for x in terms of a and b. a and b are natural numbers.

I tried taking the log of both sides, but I didn’t see any way to get the X out of the log. I also tried taking log base a, but that didn’t seem to go very far either.

I can see that there can be an answer because when I graph the equations $2^x=y$ and $x^2=y$ and look for overlap it shows two answers. I get $x=2,-0.767$.

4 Answers4

5

$$\begin{align*} a^x &= x^b\\ e^{x\ln a} &= x^b\\ 1 &= x^b e^{-x\ln a}\\ e^{k2\pi i/b} &= x e^{-(x\ln a)/b}\\ -\frac{\ln a}{b}e^{k2\pi i/b} &= -\frac{x\ln a}{b} e^{-(x\ln a)/b}\\ W\left(-\frac{\ln a}{b}e^{k2\pi i/b}\right) &= -\frac{x\ln a}{b}\\ x&= -\frac{b}{\ln a} W\left(-\frac{\ln a}{b}e^{k2\pi i/b}\right) \end{align*}$$

where $W$ is Lambert W function, $e^{k2\pi i/b}$ is a root of unity for $k = 0, 1, \ldots, b-1$.


edit: I had to mention the different roots of unity, because for example when $b=2$ as in OP's question, $-1$ is also a real square root of $1$, the argument of $W$ is real and positive, and that case leads to the $-0.767\ldots$ root.

peterwhy
  • 22,930
2

Sure. The solution is well-known for $a,b > 0$ and $a, b \in \mathbb{R}$:

$$x = -\frac{b W\left(-\frac{\log (a)}{b}\right)}{\log (a)}$$

where $W$ is Lambert's Polylog function.

2

Using the Lambert $W$ function, one may write $$ x=-\frac{bW\left(-\frac{\log a}{b} \right)}{\log a}. $$

sam wolfe
  • 3,465
2

For an alternate derivation, \begin{align} a^x &= x^b \\ a^{x/b} &= x \\ a^{1/b} &= x^{1/x} \\ \frac1b\log a &= \frac1x \log x \\ -\frac1b\log a &= \frac1x \log{\frac1x} \\ &= \log{\frac1x} e^{\log{\frac1x}} \\ W\left(-\frac1b \log a\right) &= \log{\frac1x} \\ e^{W\left(-\frac1b\log a\right)} &= \frac1x \\ x &= e^{-W\left(-\frac1b\log a\right)} \end{align} We have used the identities $\log{a^b} = b \log a$, $-\log x = \log{\frac1x}$, $x = e^{\log x}$, and $W(xe^x) = x$.

This is equivalent to the other answers by the identity $e^{-W(x)} = \frac{W(x)}x$.

Bladewood
  • 623