Prove two numbers of a set will evenly divide the other

Question

We have a set A of numbers 1, 2, 3... to 200

The question is asking me to prove that if I choose 101 numbers from the set, there will be two such that one evenly divides the other.

I know this could be the pigeonhole principle question. I could prove by contradiction that no two numbers will evenly divide each other. Assume I take 101 numbers, I can't take all the odd numbers because there is only 100 of them, so there will be an even number. I think this goes no where.

Using a direct proof if I choose 101 numbers, I will get either 100 even + 1 odd or 100 odd + 1 even. In order for two numbers to evenly divide each other I would choose the 100 even, and there is a big probability that two will be even, but if I have 100 odd + 1 even, there will be only 1 even... So I'm not sure how to solve this...

Note: 'evenly divides' doesn't mean one of the numbers are even, it means that one divides another with 0 remainder. (I'm not sure if this is what you thought, but just in case). Pick 101 elements of $A$ (I'm assuming they're all distinct, otherwise the result is trivial). What can you say about the smallest number $x$ you've picked? It's at least ... Now can you apply the pigeonhole principle to remainders of the other 100 numbers modulo $x$? — ah11950, Apr 26 '14 at 07:10
No worries. 'Evenly divides' isn't ever a term I would use... Give the question another shot now! You at least have the right idea thinking you'll need to apply pigeonhole. — ah11950, Apr 26 '14 at 07:11
@ah11950 Ok, but can I still do the worst case of 100 even + 1 odd and 100 odd + 1 even or does that not matter at all? — user3511965, Apr 26 '14 at 07:13
@ah11950 Ok so one of the boxes will be modulo 0... Working on it now. — user3511965, Apr 26 '14 at 07:14
Why 100 boxes? (This is pretty much correct, but needs a bit of justification - it's actually at most 100 boxes). If $S$ is your subset of 101 numbers in $A$, $x$ the minimal element of $S$, and $m, n \in S\setminus {x}$, what can you conclude if $m \equiv n; (\text{mod}; x)$? Indeed, does this necessarily occur? — ah11950, Apr 26 '14 at 07:18
@ah11950 I checked some website and it said you could express every integer with 2^k.m. Also I think your notation confuses me... :/ — user3511965, Apr 26 '14 at 07:23
Exact duplicate of A subset of size $101$ from $1, 2, 3, \ldots, 200$ must contain one element which divides another. — Bill Dubuque, Aug 13 '24 at 16:52

score 8 · Answer 1 · answered Apr 26 '14 at 07:23

8

Hint: The boxes will have labels $1$, $3$, $5$, and so on up to $199$. Odd labels! Note that there are $100$ boxes.

Box 1: Contains $1,2,4,8,16, 32,\dots$

Box 3: Contains $3,6,12,24, 48, \dots$

Box 5: Contains $5,10,20, 40,\dots$.

And so on.

Box 99: Contains $99,198$

Boxes 101, 103, and so on are pretty boring. Box 101 only contains the number $101$, Box 103 only contains $103$, and so on.

answered Apr 26 '14 at 07:23

André Nicolas

514,336

Hmmm... why no even boxes? – user3511965 Apr 26 '14 at 07:24
These are just labels for the boxes. They happen to be convenient. Note that (for example) if $a$ and $b$ are in box 5, then $a$ divides $b$ or $b$ divides $a$. Same with the other boxes. – André Nicolas Apr 26 '14 at 07:27

score 3 · Accepted Answer · edited Aug 18 '19 at 13:40

3

Pick $101$ elements from $A$, label them $a_1,\ldots, a_{101}$. We can assume that $a_1 < \ldots < a_{100} < a_{101}$. Since we have $101$ distinct elements, $a_1 \leq 99$.

Consider the set of remainders upon division by $a_1$. Since $a_1 \leq 99$, there are at most $98$ such remainders. Let $r_2$ be the remainder upon dividing $a_2$ by $a_1$, $r_3$ the remainder upon dividing $a_3$ by $a_1, \ldots, r_{101}$ the remainder upon dividing $a_{101}$ by $a_1$.

We have $101$ remainders $r_1,\ldots ,r_{101}$ (pigeons), and at most $98$ possible remainders (pigeonholes) upon dividing by $a_1$. Thus, by the pigeonhole principle, $r_i = r_j$ for some $1\leq i < j \leq 101$. Now what can you say about the number $a_j - a_i$?

edited Aug 18 '19 at 13:40

eem

389

answered Apr 26 '14 at 07:30

ah11950

2,750
13
20

6

but how to show that there will be two such that one evenly divides the other – Oct 01 '19 at 16:22
1

Please see https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/4525301/explaining-how-the-accepted-solution-works-of-a-previous-problem; this hint appears to not lead anywhere. – PCeltide Sep 06 '22 at 03:57

Prove two numbers of a set will evenly divide the other

2 Answers2

Linked