1

Consider an SDE $dX_t = a(t,X_t) dt + b(t,X_t)dB_t$, with initial conditions $X$ (or some distribution $\mu$ if thinking about weak solutions). I'm hoping to understand the difference between weak and strong solutions to SDEs better.

To the answer posted here, there is a comment by @Roberto Rastapopoulos that,

It may seem from this answer that a weak solution is in fact a strong solution for the right Brownian motion, but this is not the case. Indeed, the process $_$ in the weak solution need not be adapted to the filtration generated by the Brownian motion and initial condition. I think this is a key difference which deserves emphasis.

This is also mentioned in notes by Lalley (see page 1, def. 1).

However, I am curious of an example of a weak solution that is not adapted to the filtration generated by Brownian motion and the initial condition (Lalley calls this filtration the minimal filtration).

The only example I know of an SDE with a weak, but not strong, solution is the Tanaka equation. The above post describes the existence of its weak solution:

Example 3: The SDE $$dX_t = - \text{sgn}\,(X_t) \, dB_t, \qquad X_0 = 0 \tag{2}$$ has a weak solution but no strong solution.

Let's prove that the SDE has a weak solution. Let $(X_t,\mathcal{F}_t)_{t \geq 0}$ be some Brownian motion and define $$W_t := -\int_0^t \text{sgn} \, (X_s) \, dX_s.$$ It follows from Lévy's characterization that $(W_t,\mathcal{F}_t)$ is also a Brownian motion. Since $$dW_t = - \text{sgn} \, (X_t) \, dX_t$$ implies $$dX_t = - \text{sgn} \, (X_t) \, dW_t$$ this means that $(X_t)_{t \geq 0}$ is a weak solution to $(2)$.

But here, $X_t$ is (by first definition) adapted to $\mathcal{F} := (\mathcal{F}_t)_{t \geq 0}$. Moreover, it seems like the minimal filtration generated by $W_t$ is also this filtration. So the weak solution is also a strong solution with respect to this Brownian motion $(W_t,\mathcal{F}_t)$?

algebroo
  • 1,406

1 Answers1

1

Let $Y_t := |X_t|$. By Tanaka's formula, $dY_t = \text{sgn}(X_t)dX_t + dL_t$, so $-\text{sgn}(X_t)dX_t = dL_t - dY_t$. This implies \begin{align*} W_t &= \int_0^t dW_s \\ &= -\int_0^t \text{sgn}(X_s)dX_s \\ &= \int_0^t (dL_s - dY_s) \\ &= L_t - Y_t. \end{align*} Because $L_t$ and $Y_t$ are both adapted to the filtration generated by $|X_t|$, we have that $W_t$ is adapted to the filtration generated by $|X_t|$, which is strictly smaller than the filtration generated by $X_t$. Hence, $X_t$ cannot be adapted to the filtration generated by $W_t$.

user6247850
  • 14,184