5

Motivation behind the question: I've wondered since grade 10 that if $\sin(a+b),\sin(a-b)$ have formulas in terms of $\sin(a)$ and $\sin(b)$, then why not $\sin(ab)$. But I couldn't find any such information sadly.

My attempt:-

$$\sin(ab)=\sin\bigg(\frac{(a+b)^2}{4}-\frac{(a-b)^2}{4}\bigg)$$ This can be expanded as $$\sin \bigg(\frac{a+b}{2}\bigg)^2\cos \bigg(\frac{a-b}{2}\bigg)^2-\cos \bigg(\frac{a+b}{2}\bigg)^2\sin \bigg(\frac{a-b}{2}\bigg)^2$$

Now even if I try to expand the squares, I get something in the form of $\sin(a^2)$, and thus I can't run from multiplication.

Any help, or closed form solution will be greatly appreciated.

Gwen
  • 3,910
  • 6
  • 19
  • Here is an opinion that an answer does not exist: https://www.quora.com/How-do-we-know-that-a-product-rule-for-sine-doesnt-exist-I-mean-sin-ab – Red Five Apr 30 '24 at 07:38
  • 1
    @RedFive the next reply in that post answers my question somehow, with some weird name polynomials – Gwen Apr 30 '24 at 07:44
  • 4
    This question has been asked on Math.SE a few times. For instance, see here and here, which I found with a site search for sin(xy) identity. The short answer for there being no "simple" formula is that $\sin a$ and $\sin b$ are $2\pi$-periodic in both $a$ and $b$ individually, but (unless $a$ or $b$ is an integer) $\sin(ab)$ is not. – Blue Apr 30 '24 at 07:47
  • There is quite a bit in this question beyond the immediate search for an identity. Euler's formula looks like the obvious approach, even if it doesn't seem to lead very far yet. – Red Five Apr 30 '24 at 07:49
  • Thanks @Blue. They are interesting reads and having read them I'm inclined to agree, there is no "simple" formula. Whether or not there is a simple reason for this... probably doesn't matter though. – Red Five Apr 30 '24 at 07:50
  • 9
    @RedFive: The simple reason is periodicity. If $$\sin(xy)=f(\sin x, \cos x, \sin y, \cos y)$$ for some function $f$ of trig functions, then the substitution $x\to x+2\pi$ leaves the right-hand side unchanged but turns the left-hand side into $$\sin((x+2\pi)y)=\sin(xy+2y\pi)$$ which differs from $\sin(xy)$ unless $y$ is an integer. – Blue Apr 30 '24 at 08:05
  • $\sin(ab) = 3 \sin(\frac{ab}{3})-4 \sin^3(\frac{ab}{3})$ – wasu May 01 '24 at 20:52
  • @wasu Oh my. In that case $\sin(ab)=2\sin\frac{ab}{2}\cos\frac{ab}{2}$ – Gwen May 01 '24 at 21:04
  • @Gwen yes, I commented that on Dan's answer. – wasu May 02 '24 at 12:17

2 Answers2

5

Your attempt works, but I'm assuming you're in search of a formula which isolates variables $a$ and $b$.

We can derive such a formula for these by De Moivre's Theorem. $$r^n(\cos(nb) + i\sin(nb))^a = r(\cos(ab)+i\sin(ab))^n$$ Hence, rewriting this in terms of $\cos(ab)$ and $\sin(ab)$, we get: $$\cos(ab)+i\sin(ab) = (\cos(b) + i\sin(b))^a$$ Assuming $a$ is a positive integer, we get, by applying the Binomial Theorem, $$(\cos(b) + i\sin(b))^a=[\cos^a(b)+\frac{a(a-1)}{1\cdot2}\cos^{a-2}(b)\sin^2(b)+\frac{a(a-1)(a-2)(a-3)}{1\cdot2\cdot3\cdot4}\cos^{a-4}(b)\sin^4(b)]\dots+i[a\cos^{a-1}(b)\sin(b)-\frac{a(a-1)(a-2)}{1\cdot2\cdot3}\cos^{a-3}(b)\sin^3(b)\dots]$$ Now, equating the real and imaginary parts, we obtain: $$\cos(ab)={a \choose 0}\cos^a(b)-{a \choose 2}\cos^{a-2}(b)\sin^2(b)+{a \choose 4}\cos^{a-4}(b)\sin^4(b)\dots$$ $$\sin(ab)={a \choose 1}\cos^{a-1}(b)\sin(b)-{a \choose 3}\cos^{a-3}(b)\sin^3(b)+{a \choose 5}\cos^{a-5}(b)\sin^5(b)\dots$$

1

From the complex exponential definition of sine:

$$\sin(x) = \frac{e^{ix} - e^{-ix}}{2i}$$

We obtain the formula:

$$\sin(ab) = \frac{e^{iab} - e^{-iab}}{2i}$$ $$= \frac{(e^{ib})^a - (e^{-ib})^a}{2i}$$ $$= \frac{(\cos(b) + i\sin(b))^a - (\cos(-b) + i\sin(-b))^a}{2i}$$ $$= \frac{(\cos(b) + i\sin(b))^a - (\cos(b) - i\sin(b))^a}{2i}$$

If $a$ is an integer, then you can use the Binomial Theorem to expand the numerator, as in @Schrödinger's Cat's answer. For example, with $a = 2$:

$$\sin(2b) = \frac{(\cos(b) + i\sin(b))^2 - (\cos(b) - i\sin(b))^2}{2i}$$ $$= \frac{(\cos(b) + i\sin(b))^2 - (\cos(b) - i\sin(b))^2}{2i}$$ $$= \frac{\cos^2(b) + 2i\cos(b)\sin(b) - \sin^2(b) - (\cos^2(b) - 2i\cos(b)\sin(b) - \sin^2(b))}{2i}$$ $$= \frac{4i\cos(b)\sin(b)}{2i}$$ $$= 2\cos(b)\sin(b)$$

Obtaining the familiar double-angle identity.

Otherwise, I don't think there's a simple formula.

Dan
  • 18,262
  • 2
    Was $a=2$ just a random choice? A simpler formula is $\sin(ab) = 2 \cos(\frac{ab}{2})\sin(\frac{ab}{2})$. When $a=2$, we get the double-angle identity. – wasu May 01 '24 at 20:46