2

Rothe–Hagen identity states that:

$$\sum_{k=0}^{n}\frac{x}{x+kz}\binom{x+kz}{k}\ \frac{y}{y+\left(n-k\right)z}\binom{y+\left(n-k\right)z}{n-k}=\frac{x+y}{x+y+nz}\binom{x+y+nz}{n}$$ for all complex variables, except where the denominator is 0.

@Mike Spivey proved this by counting in two ways, a combinatorial proof technique.

I could not understand this algebraic proof and I'm not even sure whether this proof is complete. Please prove without using integrals, Egorychev method, Taylor series, if possible.

1 Answers1

1

The claim we set out to prove is the Rothe-Hagen identity

$$\sum_{k=0}^n \frac{x}{x+kz} {x+kz\choose k} \frac{y}{y+(n-k)z} {y+(n-k)z\choose n-k} = \frac{x+y}{x+y+nz} {x+y+nz\choose n}.$$

We prove it for $x,y,z$ positive integers and since the LHS and the RHS are in fact polynomials in $x,y,z$ (the fractional terms cancel with the corresponding binomial coefficients e.g. $\frac{x}{x+kz} {x+kz\choose k} = \frac{x}{k!} (x+kz-1)^{\underline{k-1}}$ as long as $x+kz\ne 0$ (consult problem statement)) we then have it for arbitrary values (we also get polynomials when $k=0$ or $k=n$.)

Consider the generating function $C(v)$ that satisfies the functional equation again with $z$ a positive integer

$$C(v) = 1 + v C(v)^z.$$

We ask about again with $x$ a positive integer

$$[v^k] C(v)^x = \frac{1}{k} [v^{k-1}] x C(v)^{x-1} C'(v).$$

This is by the Cauchy Coefficient Formula

$$\frac{x}{k\times 2\pi i} \int_{|v|=\epsilon} \frac{1}{v^k} C(v)^{x-1} C'(v) \; dv.$$

Here we have assumed that $C(v)$ is analytic in a neighborhood of the origin so it has a power series there with radius of convergence $\rho$ and we take $\epsilon\lt\rho.$

Now we put $C(v) = w$ and we have from the functional equation $$v = \frac{w-1}{w^z}.$$

To determine the image contour we have from the existence of the power series by calculating the first two coefficients from the functional equation that the image of $|v|=\varepsilon$ is given by $w=1+v+\cdots$ so we get a circle of radius $\varepsilon$ centered at one plus lower order terms $(\varepsilon/\rho)^2/(1-\varepsilon/\rho).$ Hence we may choose $\gamma$ such that $|w-1|=\gamma$ is entirely contained in the image of $|v|=\varepsilon$, which is contained in an annulus centered at $w=1$ which goes to $|w-1|=\varepsilon$ as $\varepsilon\ll 1$. (If it's analytic, then its got the power series, if it's got the power series then the image is in the annulus.)

This yields the integral

$$\frac{x}{k\times 2\pi i} \int_{|w-1|=\gamma} \frac{w^{zk}}{(w-1)^k} w^{x-1} \; dw.$$

The important part is that this image contour includes the pole at $w=1$, which is the only pole because we assumed that $x$ and $z$ are positive integers. Continuing,

$$\frac{x}{k\times 2\pi i} \int_{|w-1|=\gamma} \frac{1}{(w-1)^k} \sum_{p=0}^{kz+x-1} {kz+x-1\choose p} (w-1)^p\; dw \\ = \frac{x}{k} {kz+x-1\choose k-1} = \frac{x}{x+kz} {x+kz\choose k}.$$

Note that this yields the correct value including for $k=0.$

Now starting from the left of the desired identity we find

$$\sum_{k=0}^n [v^k] C_z(v)^x [v^{n-k}] C_z(v)^y = [v^n] C_z(v)^x C_z(v)^y = [v^n] C_z(v)^{x+y}.$$

This is the claim. We assumed analyticity of $C(v)$ and obtained a branch with the given binomial coefficient expansion. Now for this branch it remains to determine $\rho.$ We have for the ratio between consecutive terms

$$\frac{x+kz}{x+kz+z} {x+kz+z\choose k+1} {x+kz\choose k}^{-1} \\ = \frac{k}{k+1} {x+kz+z-1\choose k} {x+kz-1\choose k-1}^{-1} \\ = \frac{1}{k+1} \prod_{q=0}^{z-1} (x+kz+q) \prod_{q=1}^{z-1} \frac{1}{x+kz-k+q} \\ = \frac{k}{k+1} \prod_{q=0}^{z-1} (z+(x+q)/k) \prod_{q=1}^{z-1} \frac{1}{z-1+(x+q)/k}.$$

In the limit this goes to $z^z/(z-1)^{z-1}$ so that we may conclude, having determined that if the branch is analytic in a neighborhood of the origin then its series has radius of convergence $\rho=(z-1)^{z-1}/z^z \lt 1$ and its coefficients are $\frac{x}{x+kz} {x+kz\choose k}.$

The same result may be obtained using Lagrange inversion.

For the LIF computation we put $D(v) = C(v)-1$ so that we get the functional equation

$$D(v) = v (D(v) + 1)^z.$$

Using the notation from Wikipedia on LIF we have $\phi(w) = (w+1)^z$ and $H(v) = (v+1)^x$ and obtain

$$\frac{1}{k} [w^{k-1}] (x (w+1)^{x-1} ((w+1)^z)^k) = \frac{x}{k} [w^{k-1}] (1+w)^{kz+x-1} = \frac{x}{k} {kz+x-1\choose k-1}.$$

This matches the first result.

Marko Riedel
  • 64,728