Suppose that $G\cong H$ are isomorphic groups whose non-identity elements are all of order 2. Fix $g \in G$ and $h \in H$ with $g\neq 1$ and $h\neq 1$. My question is does there exist an isomorphism from $G$ to $H$ taking $g$ to $h?$
My guess is that we can construct such an isomorphism from the given one, but I haven't quite been able to make this work, so maybe it is not true?