6

It is well known that Boolean valued models play significant roles for set-theoretic purposes. But how well-studied are Boolean valued models in a more general setting, as models for random first-order languages?

For example, towards the end of chapter 0 of Bell's "Set Theory: Boolean Valued Models and Independence Proofs", Bell gives the definition of a Boolean-algebra-valued $\mathscr{L}$ structure where $\mathscr{L}$ is a first order language whose sole extralogical symbol is a binary predicate $P$:

A Boolean-algebra valued $\mathscr{L}$ structure is a quadruple $\mathbf{M} = (M, eq, Q, B)$, where $M$ is a non-empty class, $B$ is a complete Boolean algebra and $eq$ and $Q$ are maps from $M \times M \rightarrow H$ satisfying, for all $m, n, m', n'\in M$,

$$ eq(m, m)=1, eq(m, n)=eq(n,m), eq(m,n) \land eq (n, n') \le eq(m, n'), Q(m,n) \land eq(m, m') \le Q (m', n), Q(m,n) \land eq(n, n') \le Q(m, n') $$

For any formula $\phi$ of $\mathscr{L}$ and finite finite sequence $\mathbf{x} = <x_1, ..., x_n>$ of variables of $\mathscr{L}$ containing all the free variables of $\phi$, define for any Boolean-valued $\mathscr{L}$ structure $\mathbf{M}$ a map

$$ ‖\phi‖^{M_x}: M^n \rightarrow B $$

recursively as follows:

$‖x_p = x_q‖^{M_x} = <m_1, ..., m_n> \mapsto eq(m_p, m_q),$

$‖Px_px_q‖^{M_x} = <m_1, ..., m_n> \mapsto Q(m_p, m_q),$

$‖\phi \land \psi‖^{M_x} = ‖\phi‖^{M_x} \land ‖\psi‖^{M_x}$, and similarly for other connectives,

$‖\exists y \phi‖^{M_x} = <m_1, ..., m_n> \mapsto \bigvee_{m \in M} ‖\phi(y/u)‖^{M_{ux}}(m, m_1, ..., m_n)$,

$‖\forall y \phi‖^{M_x} = <m_1, ..., m_n> \mapsto \bigwedge_{m \in M} ‖\phi(y/u)‖^{M_{ux}}(m, m_1, ..., m_n)$

That definition, it seems to me, can be easily generalized to a random first order language with other predicate, constant, or function symbols. And Bells mentions that it can be shown that a formula $\phi$ is $\mathbf{M}$-valid for all $\mathbf{M}$ (a forluma $\phi$ is $\mathbf{M}$-valid just in case $‖\phi‖^{M_x}$ is identically 1) iff $\phi$ is provable in classical first-order logic.

So I'm wondering if there are other interesting results on Boolean-valued models as models for arbitrary first order languages. Or in general, how well-studied is the theory of Boolean valued models, as models for random first order languages? How much of traditional model theory (the theory of 2-valued models of first order languages) can be generalized to Boolean valued models? Are there any books or articles on this topic?

Thanks!

  • I think that this wound up getting subsumed by more general categorical logic, especially the development of model theory in an arbitrary topos. See Loullis' Sheaves and Boolean valued model theory (the bibliography of which contains the possibly-relevant-but-hard-to-find Ph.D. thesis of Shorb, Contributions to Boolean-valued model theory). – Noah Schweber Jun 23 '21 at 18:37

0 Answers0